Excalibur Dehydrator Trays Compared: The Quick Decision Guide

As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.

Upgrading or outfitting a food dehydrator requires deciding between flexible polyscreen mesh inserts, rigid stainless steel replacement racks, and raised-edge non-stick silicone mats. Choosing the right excalibur dehydrator trays comes down to what you dry, how you handle cleanup, and whether your dehydrator cabinet already contains base support shelves. Sliced meats and whole fruits thrive on breathable mesh surfaces, while pureed fruit leathers, crackers, and liquid egg mixtures immediately spill through standard grids unless paired with a sealed, lipped border.

The market for excalibur replacement trays separates clearly into three distinct functional categories across five-tray and nine-tray machine formats. First are the authentic flexible plastic screen inserts intended to nest inside existing hard plastic outer frames. Second are heavy-duty stainless steel excalibur dehydrator trays engineered to replace plastic entirely, allowing food to rest directly on non-toxic metal grids. Third are specialized silicone dehydrator sheets for excalibur that drop over metal or plastic bases to manage wet, sticky mixtures without sticking. Understanding how these materials interact with your dehydrator cabinet will clarify which excalibur dehydrator trays to buy for your kitchen routine.

Criteria matrix What each model in this report is credited with

Rows are the criteria that come up in the pros and cons listed for this lineup. A check means the criterion is named in this report’s write-up of that model; a dash means it is not. Criteria that apply to every model, or to only one, are left out because they separate nothing.

Criterion	Excalibur 14" x 14" 8.6/10	9 Stainless Steel Trays 8.2/10	3 Stainless Steel Trays 8.2/10	SFV 6 Pack Silicone 8.6/10	8 Pack Silicone Dehydrator 9.6/10	6 Pcs Silicone Dehydrator 9.4/10
Inches	Not named	✓Named	✓Named	✓Named	✓Named	✓Named
Silicone	✓Named	Not named	Not named	✓Named	✓Named	✓Named
Percent	Not named	✓Named	✓Named	✓Named	Not named	✓Named
Shelves	✓Named	✓Named	✓Named	Not named	✓Named	Not named
Stainless steel	Not named	✓Named	✓Named	Not named	✓Named	Not named
Metal construction	Not named	✓Named	✓Named	Not named	Not named	Not named
Plastic mesh	✓Named	✓Named	Not named	Not named	Not named	Not named
Food contact	Not named	✓Named	✓Named	Not named	Not named	Not named
Criteria named	3 / 8	7 / 8	6 / 8	3 / 8	4 / 8	3 / 8

Built from the wording of this report, not from a bench test. A dash is not a fault: it only means the write-up does not mention that point for that model. Scores next to each model are out of 10, based on listed specifications and buyer feedback.

Excalibur Dehydrator Trays Lineup at a Glance

The Models in Detail

Excalibur 14″ x 14″ Polyscreen Mesh

Best for: Standard drying on factory Excalibur shelves

Pros

• Official OEM flexible design
• Full nine tray coverage
• Food safe plastic mesh

Cons

• Requires existing rigid frames
• Not suited for liquids

The Excalibur 14″ x 14″ Polyscreen Mesh pack is the authentic factory screen solution designed specifically for owners of five-tray and nine-tray cabinets. Built with model number P43 specifications, this set includes nine individual square screen inserts finished in black. The mesh pattern provides balanced airflow from rear-mounted fans while preventing small herbs, sliced strawberries, and chopped vegetables from falling down through the cabinet floor as they shrink during dehydration.

Because these are flexible inserts, they are not rigid shelves on their own. They must sit directly inside an existing rigid tray framework to support heavier foods. The food-safe plastic construction allows you to bend the screen to pop off dried jerky strips or fruit slices that might otherwise cling to solid metal. If your original factory screens have warped or accumulated stubborn stains over years of regular use, this set restores factory functionality across an entire nine-tray dehydrator cabinet.

This mesh insert pack suits dehydrator owners who already have functional outer tray frames and want an exact manufacturer replacement. It provides the best trays for excalibur dehydrator users who primarily dry solid items like sliced jerky, leafy greens, banana chips, and orchard fruits. It yields to solid or silicone options whenever you work with purees, liquid doughs, or high-moisture foods that drip.

9 Stainless Steel Trays Compatible

Best for: Complete plastic free dehydrator overhauls

Pros

• Full nine tray stainless steel setup
• Eliminates plastic mesh sheets
• Rigid standalone metal construction

Cons

• Requires hand washing
• Heavier than plastic

For cooks aiming to remove heated plastics from their food preservation process, the 9 Stainless Steel Trays Compatible set provides a complete cabinet overhaul. Manufactured by Bright Kitchen under model SStray149, these heavy-duty shelves measure 15 inches square and slide directly into the cabinet runners of five-tray and nine-tray units. Built entirely from 100 percent food-grade stainless steel, they provide a level shelf structure that eliminates the need for any secondary plastic mesh inserts.

Placing meat, poultry, and wet produce directly onto metal wire shelves mimics commercial horizontal air distribution similar to configurations found in a magic mill dehydrator. The rigid steel mesh resists bending, cracking, or breaking under the weight of thick meat slabs, making it significantly more durable than original plastic frames. The listing specifies that these trays should be washed by hand or wiped down with a damp cloth rather than run through a high-heat sanitizing cycle.

This nine-piece metal set is designed for high-volume processors who want an all-metal food contact surface and a permanent replacement for plastic shelving. It gives way to smaller bundles if you only want to test metal shelves, and it requires supplemental non-stick sheets if you plan to dehydrate purees or liquid batters.

3 Stainless Steel Trays Compatible

Best for: Gradual metal shelf replacement

Pros

• Durable 100 percent stainless steel
• Direct food contact without mesh
• Fits five and nine tray units

Cons

• Only three shelves included
• Requires hand washing

The 3 Stainless Steel Trays Compatible bundle offers the exact same heavy-duty metal construction as the larger nine-pack, but in a three-tray configuration under model number SStray143. Manufactured by Bright Kitchen, each square shelf measures 15 inches by 15 inches and fits securely into the tracks of both five-tray and nine-tray units. This package allows you to upgrade your machine incrementally rather than replacing an entire cabinet set in a single purchase.

Using stainless steel shelves allows you to load heavy marinades and acidic fruit slices directly onto the metal surface without worrying about long-term plastic degradation or persistent odor retention. Because these metal racks function as self-supporting shelves, you do not need original plastic frames or supplementary mesh screens to hold your food. Slices sit straight on the metal grid, promoting total air contact around the perimeter of every item.

This three-pack is ideal for dehydrator owners who only dedicate a few shelves to heavy, greasy meats or who want to replace broken plastic racks on a budget. It suits cooks testing stainless steel excalibur dehydrator trays before committing to a full machine conversion. It gives way to the full nine-tray pack if you run your machine at maximum capacity every batch.

SFV 6 Pack Silicone Dehydrator Trays

Best for: High temperature fruit leather and purees

Pros

• Heat safe up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit
• Raised lip contains liquids
• Dishwasher safe silicone

Cons

• Requires base tray for support
• Listing package count discrepancy

The SFV 6 Pack Silicone Dehydrator Trays are flexible mats designed specifically to handle liquid ingredients and sticky foods that ruin standard mesh screens. Sized at 14 inches by 14 inches, these brown silicone liners feature a distinct raised perimeter lip that traps runaway liquids, fruit roll purees, blended eggs, and wet crackers. The listing notes that the material handles extreme temperature swings ranging from -40 degrees Fahrenheit up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit.

Maintaining spotless food surfaces requires low-residue cleaning, and unlike household fabric care managed with a seventh generation laundry detergent sheet, kitchen silicone simply rinses clean with warm dish soap or cleans thoroughly in a dishwasher. The 100 percent BPA-free natural silicone will not deform under heat, and fruit leathers peel away smoothly without needing cooking sprays. The listing emphasizes that these flexible sheets cannot be used alone inside the cabinet runners; they must rest on top of a hard base tray.

This set suits users who specialize in liquid recipes, blended fruit leathers, homemade crackers, and raw food baking. It is the proper choice when standard excalibur 14×14 dehydrator trays cannot contain runny liquids. It gives way to open wire or mesh racks whenever you dry whole jerky strips or apple slices that demand unrestricted top-and-bottom airflow.

8 Pack Silicone Dehydrator Sheets

Best for: Versatile oven and dehydrator liquid drying

Pros

• Extra thick construction
• Eight pack covers full units
• Dishwasher safe food grade silicone

Cons

• One month limited warranty
• Flexible handling when loaded

The 8 Pack Silicone Dehydrator Sheets package from Nucucina delivers extensive coverage for dehydrator owners running near-capacity eight-tray or nine-tray batches. Each brown mat measures 14 inches by 14 inches and incorporates a built-in raised edge to retain fluid mixtures. Built under model number ZN-DT-S8, these food-grade silicone mats are BPA-free, non-stick, and compatible with both dehydrator cabinets and standard kitchen ovens.

A notable claim in the listing is that this silicone tray is extra thick, allowing it to be placed inside an outer metal tray or used on its own. While the material is flexible enough for oven baking and rolling sponge cakes, placing it on a sturdy base shelf prevents spills when sliding loaded trays into horizontal slots. The mats clean easily by hand or in the dishwasher and come with a 1-month warranty from the manufacturer.

This eight-pack is ideal for busy cooks who prepare large volumes of fruit roll-ups, vegetable leathers, or dehydrated eggs in a single session. It offers almost complete coverage for a nine-tray cabinet without buying multiple small accessories. It yields to rigid stainless steel shelves when you need maximum load capacity for dense, heavy foods.

6 Pcs Silicone Dehydrator Sheets

Best for: Lining standard fourteen inch metal trays

Pros

• Raised lip edge retains moisture
• BPA free non stick silicone
• Six pack quantity

Cons

• Measures 13.5 inches square
• Requires separate supporting tray

The 6 Pcs Silicone Dehydrator Sheets bundle provides a tailored liner option with dimensions measuring 13.5 inches by 13.5 inches. Engineered by Generic under part number awffgg, these brown silicone mats are designed to drop cleanly inside standard 14-inch by 14-inch metal trays. The slightly smaller perimeter ensures the mat rests flat against the tray floor without riding up along the outer framing rails of your dehydrator.

Careful kitchen organization parallels the structured storage found when arranging tools in westling socket trays, and keeping your dehydrator trays properly lined prevents sticky messes from baking onto the machine floor. Each liner features a raised perimeter lip to stop liquid from running off the edges during loading. The 100 percent food-grade silicone construction is BPA-free, non-stick, and heat resistant, making it simple to peel away thin sheets of vegetable jerky or dehydrated yogurt snacks.

This six-pack is best for dehydrator owners whose base trays have an inner footprint slightly under 14 inches, preventing edge buckling. It gives way to true 14-inch or 15-inch full-coverage mats if you want to maximize every square inch of available drying surface area on larger shelves.

Matching a Model to Your Setup

• Refreshing an original nine-tray cabinet for produce and jerky: The Excalibur 14″ x 14″ Polyscreen Mesh provides nine OEM-spec flexible inserts that drop directly into your existing outer frames to restore reliable airflow for sliced goods.
• Eliminating all heated plastic from your dehydrating workflow: The 9 Stainless Steel Trays Compatible package supplies a full cabinet set of 15-inch metal shelves so food never touches plastic during dehydration.
• Gradual tray upgrades or heavy meat smoking batches: The 3 Stainless Steel Trays Compatible bundle lets you replace broken racks or dedicate three dedicated metal levels to messy, marinated jerky strips.
• Making fruit leathers with maximum oven temperature tolerance: The SFV 6 Pack Silicone Dehydrator Trays withstand temperatures up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit while raised edges contain liquid mixtures.
• Outfitting an entire eight-shelf or nine-shelf unit for purees: The 8 Pack Silicone Dehydrator Sheets delivers broad batch capacity with thick, non-stick silicone surfaces that peel cleanly away from dried leathers.
• Lining inner tray bases with narrower internal dimensions: The 6 Pcs Silicone Dehydrator Sheets measures 13.5 inches square to drop smoothly into 14-inch trays without riding up the outer lip.

Before You Buy

Before purchasing replacement trays or liners, confirm the exact tray framework your dehydrator cabinet uses. Authentic mesh screen inserts and silicone mats are flexible liners, not rigid shelves. The listings explicitly state that flexible silicone sheets cannot support heavy foods alone and must sit atop a hard metal or plastic base rack. If your dehydrator lacks the underlying rigid outer shelves, purchasing silicone sheets or polyscreen mesh alone will leave you without a way to slide food into the cabinet rails. Only the standalone stainless steel models serve as self-supporting structural shelves.

Check dimensional measurements carefully between 13.5-inch, 14-inch, and 15-inch options. While five-tray and nine-tray cabinets accommodate standard 15-inch outer shelves, internal tray basins vary depending on frame thickness. The listings do not specify universal dishwasher compatibility for the stainless steel models, recommending hand cleaning and damp wiping instead. Review your machine dimensions and recipe plans so you choose the exact surface type your dehydrating routine demands.

FAQ

Are all Excalibur dehydrator trays interchangeable across five and nine tray models?

Yes, standard 5-tray and 9-tray cabinets share the same internal cabinet width and shelf runner spacing. Trays measuring 15 inches by 15 inches slide interchangeably into both cabinet sizes. The primary difference is simply total vertical capacity: a five-tray unit uses five shelves, while a nine-tray cabinet holds up to nine shelves simultaneously.

Do silicone sheets require an underlying hard tray to hold food in an Excalibur unit?

In almost every case, yes. The listings for flexible silicone sheets clarify that they lack the rigid structural strength to slide into cabinet tracks on their own when loaded with heavy food or liquids. You must place them over an existing plastic frame or stainless steel shelf for support, though one thick model listing mentions it can be used alone under lighter loads.

Can stainless steel replacement trays go into a standard dishwasher?

The product care instructions for the stainless steel models explicitly specify hand washing or wiping down with a damp cloth. While stainless steel is inherently durable and non-toxic, the manufacturer listing does not state that these mesh shelves are dishwasher safe. Hand washing preserves the wire welds and prevents premature discoloration.

How does polyscreen mesh compare to solid silicone sheets for making beef jerky?

Polyscreen mesh is superior for traditional whole-muscle beef jerky because its open grid allows warm air to circulate beneath the meat, speeding up dehydration and ensuring even drying. Solid silicone sheets with raised edges are designed for wet purees, fruit leathers, and crackers where liquid would otherwise drip through open mesh holes.

Why do some silicone dehydrator sheets measure 13.5 inches instead of 14 inches?

A 13.5-inch sheet is engineered to fit neatly inside the recessed basin of a 14-inch rigid outer tray. If a silicone liner is exactly the same size as the outer frame, the raised edges can ride up along the frame border, creating uneven surfaces. The 13.5-inch sizing guarantees a flat resting position inside standard outer racks.